Acasă Articole RTR Nicoleta Cliveț, Eugen Simion – între certitudinile guelfului și melancoliile ghibelinului

Nicoleta Cliveț, Eugen Simion – între certitudinile guelfului și melancoliile ghibelinului


Eugen Simion – between the uncertainty of the Guelph and the melancholy of the Ghibelline

The distinction Guelph vs. Ghibelline made by Roland Barthes, frequently invoked by Eugen Simion, could be considered a metaphor of the work of literary criticism carried out by the second one. Just like a Solar, Apollonian Guelph, with the building, valuing and hierarchy vocation, E. Simion begins his critical path with well documented, analytical and descriptive studies, professorial even, whether they are about the monographs dedicated to M. Eminescu and E. Lovinescu, or they are oriented towards the postwar literature, to the canonization of which he contributed. In the volumes preceding “Time to Live, Time to Confess”, the critic is searching for a theme which is comprehensive enough to allow him to be both objective and subjective, methodical and pert, voluble and friendly. With the volume “The Parisian Journal”, he finds his own theme – the biographical, “the death of the author”, and thus becomes a Ghibelline – bound to the concrete, the materiality of the world, to the show of the individuality and even to pleasure (reading including). But the reveries and the melancholy of the Ghibelline have not replaced, only competed with the Guelph certainties. Although “Time to Live, Time to Confess” is not only his most friendly and vivid book, but also the most read and appreciated by colleagues, its author has not only persevered on the path opened by discovering his own “creative spirit figure”, but has also continued to write academic literary criticism as well, in an attempt to carry both the Guelph and Ghibelline’s battles. This fight on two fronts deprived the Ghibelline intuitions of the exclusive attention it would have deserved.
Keywords: postwar literary criticism, axiological perspective, lovinescianism, calinescianism, thematism, critical revisionism, intimism, literary canon.

  • Gheorghe Grigurcu, Critici români de azi / Romanian Critics of Today, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1981.
  • Nicolae Manolescu, Istoria critică a literaturii române / Critical History of Romanian Literature, Piteşti, Ed. Paralela 45, 2009.
  • Lucian Raicu, Critica – formă de viaţă/ Criticism – a Way of Life, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1976.
  • Lucian Raicu, Fragmente de timp / Scraps of Time,Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1984.
  • Cornel Regman, Colocvial / Colloquial, Bucureşti, Ed. Eminescu, 1976.
  • Eugen Simion, Proza lui Eminescu / Eminescu’s Prose, Bucureşti, EPL, 1964.
  • Eugen Simion, Orientări în literatura contemporană / Orientations in Contemporary Literature, Bucureşti, EPL, 1965.
  • Eugen Simion, Timpul trăirii, timpul mărturisirii. Jurnal parizian / Time to Live, Time to Confess. The Parisian Journal, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1977.
  • Eugen Simion, Eugen Lovinescu, scepticul mântuit / Eugen Lovinescu, the Expiated Sceptic Bucureşti, Ed. Grai şi Suflet – Cultura naţională, 1996, ediţia a II-a revăzută şi adăugită.
  • Eugen Simion, Sfidarea retoricii. Jurnal german / Defying Rhetoric. The German Journal, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1985.
  • Eugen Simion, Scriitori români de azi I / Romanian Writers of Today I, Bucureşti, Ed. Carte Românească, 1978, ediţia a II-a revăzută şi adăugită.
  • Eugen Simion, Scriitori români de azi II / Romanian Writers of Today II, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1976.
  • Eugen Simion, Scriitori români de azi III / Romanian Writers of Today III, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1984.
  • Eugen Simion, Scriitori români de azi IV / Romanian Writers of Today IV, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1989.
  • Eugen Simion, În ariergarda avangardei (convorbiri cu Andrei Grigor) / Behind the Avant-garde (Conversations with Andrei Gligor), Bucureşti, Ed. Univers Enciclopedic, 2004.
  • Eugen Simion, Întoarcerea autorului / The Return of the Author, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1981.
  • Eugen Simion, Dimineaţa poeţilor / The Poets’ Morning, Bucureşti, Ed. Cartea Românească, 1980.
  • Eugen Simion, Moartea lui Mercutio / Mercutio’s Death, Bucureşti, Ed. Nemira, 1993.
  • Eugen Simion, Ficţiunea jurnalului intim / The Fiction of the Diary Bucureşti, Ed. Univers Enciclopedic, 2001.